Vincent Snickers

Home / Writings / Text VIII

VIII

The parable of the talents

The fear of doing badly and the potential we dare not live

By Vincent Snickers · 6 min read

We hold caution to be a virtue and think that attempting nothing does no harm to anyone. The parable of the talents has maintained the opposite for two thousand years. It condemns the only servant who lost nothing.

Paul Klee, The Goldfish, 1925.
Paul Klee, The Goldfish, 1925.

The fear of doing badly

You have a project in a drawer, something you know how to do and do not show. You are waiting to be ready, or to be allowed.

This fear is growing. In 2019 Thomas Curran and Andrew Hill brought together the responses of 41,641 American, Canadian and British students, collected from 1989 to 2016. The perfectionism we believe others demand of us rose by 33%.

What we believe is simple. Doing nothing seems wise. We lose nothing and do not expose ourselves. As for the parable, a morality of productivity has been drawn from it, in which each of us must make our gifts bear fruit for God or for society.

The story punishes the one who risked nothing

A rich master sets off on a long journey. He entrusts money to three servants. Five talents to the first, two to the second, one to the last. In Matthew, he gives them no instructions. None.

The first two make what they received bear fruit. The last is afraid of losing. He hides his talent in the earth. On his return, the master welcomes the first two into his joy. The last comes trembling: I knew that you are a hard man; here is what is yours. He has given everything back, to the last penny. He is cast out.

Our spontaneous judgement runs the other way. In 1991 Mark Spranca, Elisa Minsk and Jonathan Baron showed that, where the consequences are equal, many of us judge a harm caused by refraining less severely than the same harm caused by acting. The parable reverses exactly this judgement. And studies of regret partly bear it out, since the share of regrets concerning what we did not do grows with the years.

What is entrusted is your will

In the ancient world, the talent is a unit of weight. A talent of silver represents some fifteen years of a labourer’s wages. The master is entrusting a fortune. And the word “talent”, in the sense of a personal gift, comes from this parable.

Each servant stands face to face with himself. It falls to him to act with complete autonomy, from his own will and preferences. The third is condemned because he was afraid of acting wrongly and of being judged by an authority, even were it God. The wealth entrusted is your will. It is, in Spinoza, the expansion of being and joy, that joy which is the passage to a greater power of acting. It is, in Nietzsche, the will to power. I read this parable as the portrait of the man who dares not act by himself and who needs a master.

one talentthe image of ahard manhis ownjudgementBURYINVESTreturned intactnothing lost, nothing liveddoubled“enter into the joy”fear’s reckoninga loss weighs double, abstaining costs nothingthe parable’s reckoningwhat is not invested is already lost
The same talent, two gestures. Fear and the parable do not keep the same accounts, and that is why the cautious servant does not understand his condemnation.

The story contains two details that are seldom noticed.

It is the one who received the least who buries. I read it like this: we do not bury our talent because it is too great, we bury it because we judge it too small to be worth the risk.

The “hard man” is, in the first place, the servant who says so. The master does not deny it; he turns the word back on him. You knew that I reap where I have not sown, so you ought to have put my money to work. In Luke’s version, he says it plainly: out of your own mouth will I judge you. The servant is treated according to the image he has formed of the master. In 1991 Paul Hewitt and Gordon Flett distinguished three forms of perfectionism, and one of those most closely linked to distress is the one we believe others expect of us.

His fear has a more precise name. Guilt is the fear of having acted wrongly. Shame is the fear of being seen as inadequate. The servant does nothing wrong. He hides, and we hide out of shame.

A natural inclination does the rest. In 1979 Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky showed that a loss weighs more heavily than a gain of the same size, roughly twice as much according to their 1992 estimate.

Dostoevsky sets out the same choice in The Brothers Karamazov, when the Grand Inquisitor reproaches Christ for having left men free. On one side freedom, on the other a servitude in which you are told what is. You no longer have to think, to feel, to imagine. You are told what to do, and you are given bread. Faced with the long indictment, Christ makes no reply. He kisses the old man.

Abstaining ceases to be a shelter

To bury one’s talent is to bury one’s being out of fear. This observation is not a new verdict. To blame oneself for having buried one’s talent is to give the hard man back his place.

Not every talent set aside is buried. One can give up a gift because one prefers another, and that choice is the opposite of fear. The buried talent can be recognised by two things: you still think about it, and you avoid those who might see it.

It remains to distinguish caution from fear. Caution assesses a risk, chooses a stake and can say under what conditions it would act. Fear refuses any stake and never finds the conditions met.

The third servant can be recognised by a few habits.

The system in a table
Facing a riskWhat it waits forWhat it says
CautionAssesses it and sets a stakeConditions it can name“I’ll try if”
FearRefuses any stakePermission“Now is not the time”

Buried talent = freedom received without instructions × the image of a severe judge. All three servants have the first. Only the third has the second.

Exercise, the smallest investment

Which talent have you buried? Name it. Then name the master whose judgement you dreaded on the day you buried it. Does he still have authority over you?

Then put this talent to work this week, on the smallest possible scale. One page, a quarter of an hour, in front of a single person.

Further reading
  • Gospel of Matthew 25:14–30. Gospel of Luke 19:11–27.
  • Fyodor Dostoevsky, The Brothers Karamazov, “The Grand Inquisitor”.
  • Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, “Prospect theory”, Econometrica, 1979.
  • Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman, “Advances in prospect theory”, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1992.
  • Mark Spranca, Elisa Minsk and Jonathan Baron, “Omission and commission in judgment and choice”, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1991.
  • Paul L. Hewitt and Gordon L. Flett, “Perfectionism in the self and social contexts”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1991.
  • Thomas Gilovich and Victoria H. Medvec, “The experience of regret”, Psychological Review, 1995.
  • Thomas Curran and Andrew P. Hill, “Perfectionism is increasing over time”, Psychological Bulletin, 2019.

If this text speaks to you, a first twenty-minute conversation is a chance to talk about it. Book a first conversation

20 min · free of charge Choose a time