Vincent Snickers

Home / Writings / Text IX

IX

The child, third metamorphosis

Camel, lion, child: Nietzsche’s three metamorphoses explained

By Vincent Snickers · 6 min read

You got what you wanted, and the weariness came back. You had been told that freedom consists in knowing what you want and getting it. Nietzsche foresaw this disappointment. After duty and after revolt, there remains a third metamorphosis.

Wassily Kandinsky, Sky Blue, 1940.
Wassily Kandinsky, Sky Blue, 1940.

Succeeding, and staying weary

You have left what weighed on you. You have reached your goals, and something is still missing. I once saw a man who had accomplished a great deal, in every area, and who remained weary. Each time, he believed the next success would satisfy him.

We usually believe that duty is opposed to desire. On one side what is imposed on me, on the other what I want. Freeing oneself would mean passing from the first to the second. A large part of personal development stops there.

Getting what you want is not enough, and where does what I want come from?

In 2009 Christopher Niemiec, Richard Ryan and Edward Deci questioned young graduates one year and then two years after they finished their studies. Those who attained goals of money, fame and image drew no greater well-being from them, and tended rather to show more signs of ill-being. Only goals of personal growth, relationships and community involvement brought it.

Nietzsche had told the story. The camel believes that duty leads to an oasis, and discovers a desert for life. Then occurs what Jung, after Heraclitus, calls an enantiodromia, a running in the opposite direction. The camel becomes a lion.

The lion says “I will” instead of “I must”. But he faces a dragon on whose every scale is written “thou shalt”. His desire was born of a reversal: he still defines himself in relation to the collective. René Girard argued that we most often desire according to a model, what others already desire. You are asked what you want while the answer is already being whispered to you: health, seduction, money.

The lion too has his desert. I recognise in it the one measured by the 2009 study.

The child wants neither against others nor like them

Nietzsche describes it thus. “The child is innocence and forgetting, a new beginning, a game, a self-propelled wheel, a first movement, a sacred ‘Yes’.”

The child does not want the values that glitter on the dragon’s scales. He wants his own subjectivity, as vital impulse and as preference, the one that puts him in touch with the games he wants to play. He apes no one. His forgetting does not erase desire; it erases the debt.

CHILDI createCAMELI mustLIONI willWHOLEMANthe end of the desert: duty turns into revoltthe second desert:wanting whatothers wantloyalty to the collectivewillplay,preference
The two black arrows are the metamorphoses. The three green arrows show what each figure brings to the whole man, who stands at the centre and cannot be reduced to any one corner.

The lion has two faces, which I bring together. Nietzsche’s wants against: he conquers his freedom by saying no. The one I describe wants like: he takes his desires from those he admires. In both cases, the measure remains outside him.

The child has his counterfeits, and he must be told apart from them.

Wanting and preferring. The lion’s wanting needs spectators. The child’s preference may have recipients, but it has no need of spectators.

The child and the eternal adolescent. Marie-Louise von Franz described the puer aeternus, who keeps every possibility open and commits to none. Zarathustra’s child, by contrast, creates. A game has rules, and one keeps to them.

Play and entertainment. Entertainment makes us forget; play engages us. We come out of the first rested and a little empty, out of the second tired and more alive.

Play is in no way a regression. The historian Johan Huizinga argued that it precedes culture and founds it. For Winnicott, it is in playing that the individual is able to be creative and to use the whole personality.

And we know how it is lost. In 1973 Mark Lepper, David Greene and Richard Nisbett observed nursery-school children who liked to draw. To some of them they promised a reward. One to two weeks later, those children drew less when left free to choose. Those who had received the same reward without its being promised drew as much as before. It is the contract that does the damage, not the gift.

A single question separates the lion from the child

Faced with what you are pursuing, ask yourself whether you would still want it supposing no one could ever give you credit for it. This is the question of the secret. It does not rule out other people, since teaching, healing or passing something on all presuppose someone to whom one is speaking. It rules out only the spectator.

It is not a matter of being only the child, or one ends up like Diogenes, cut loose from the collective. The whole man is a chimera of camel, lion and child. He is capable of “I must”, loyal to the values of the collective. He is capable of “I will”, with awareness and measure. And he leaves room for the child.

An artist had given up passing on a knowledge that mattered to her, out of shame at an ambition her milieu would have disapproved of. She reconnected with that impulse and gave herself the means to keep up the game she wanted to play.

A weariness that persists after success, with sleep or energy affected, can also signal depression, and warrants seeing a doctor.

The system in one table
FigureWhat moves itWhat it lacksIts risk
CamelDutyPlayThe desert
LionA desire taken from othersA preference of its ownA second desert
Eternal adolescentPlay without commitmentStaying powerNothing comes to fruition
ChildA game chosen and kept upThe bond with the collective, if left aloneEnding up like Diogenes

Child = one’s own preference + play + commitment. Without commitment, the eternal adolescent. Without play, the camel. Without one’s own preference, the lion.

Exercise

What did you play at as a child, without anyone asking you to? What resembles it in your life today? If there is nothing, look for its smallest possible form and give it an hour this week.

Then take what you are pursuing at the moment and ask the question of the secret.

Further reading
  • Friedrich Nietzsche, Thus Spoke Zarathustra, “On the Three Metamorphoses”, trans. Walter Kaufmann.
  • Johan Huizinga, Homo Ludens, 1938.
  • René Girard, Deceit, Desire and the Novel, 1961.
  • Marie-Louise von Franz, The Problem of the Puer Aeternus, 1970.
  • Donald W. Winnicott, Playing and Reality, 1971.
  • Mark R. Lepper, David Greene and Richard E. Nisbett, “Undermining children’s intrinsic interest with extrinsic reward”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1973.
  • Christopher P. Niemiec, Richard M. Ryan and Edward L. Deci, “The path taken”, Journal of Research in Personality, 2009.

If this text speaks to you, a first twenty-minute conversation is a chance to talk about it. Book a first conversation

20 min · free of charge Choose a time