Vincent Snickers

Home / Writings / Text X

X

The courage of chaos

Daring to change your life when nothing is guaranteed

By Vincent Snickers · 7 min read

You stay in a situation that no longer suits you, and you call it prudence. An experiment carried out with thousands of people who were hesitating suggests something else. Those who made the change said they were happier six months later. What holds us back is often how hard it is to bear not knowing.

Ivan Aivazovsky, Chaos, 1841.
Ivan Aivazovsky, Chaos, 1841.

“I know what I have”

You are not happy in this job, this relationship, this city, and you have known it for a long time. When people ask you why you stay, you answer: “I know what I have; I don’t know what I would find.”

The economist Steven Levitt offered thousands of internet users who could not make up their minds the chance to settle their choice with the toss of a coin, then contacted them again. For important decisions, leaving a job or a relationship, those who had made the change said they were happier six months later than those who had stayed. He concludes, with caution, that people who hesitate for a long time over such a choice would more often gain by changing. His participants were volunteers and were already hesitating. The result says nothing about those who never ask themselves the question.

We tell ourselves that staying is not a choice, merely the absence of choice, and that it is wise to wait until we are sure before moving.

Staying is a choice, and it is favoured in advance

In 1988 William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser showed that an option is chosen more often as soon as it is presented as the current situation, all other things being equal. Staying has the advantage of not looking like a choice.

As early as 1961 Daniel Ellsberg had argued that we prefer a bet with known odds to a bet with unknown odds, even when nothing suggests the first is better.

As for “waiting until you are sure”, certainty never comes.

Not everything that holds us back is a bias, though. Children, a mortgage, a residence permit are reasons. And in a violent relationship, separation is the most dangerous moment. It should be prepared with specialist help.

We cannot bear not knowing

In 1998 Michel Dugas and his colleagues put forward the idea that chronic worry has less to do with the dangers themselves than with intolerance of uncertainty. Here I extend their idea. The sentence “I know what I have” is accurate. It simply shows that the unknown costs you more than unhappiness.

Risk and uncertainty. The economist Frank Knight separated them in 1921. We speak of risk when the probabilities are known, of uncertainty when they cannot be calculated. The great decisions of a life belong to the second. To demand guarantees is to ask uncertainty to behave like risk.

Fear and anxiety. Kierkegaard distinguishes them in 1844. Fear has an object. Anxiety has none: it stands before the possible, and he calls it the dizziness of freedom. Fear asks us to protect ourselves. Anxiety asks us to choose.

Anxiety and anxiety disorder. The anxiety Kierkegaard speaks of accompanies a real choice and subsides once one has chosen. In anxiety disorder, worry attaches itself to everything, keeps you awake and no longer depends on any decision. The first is something you go through. The second is something you treat, and it responds well to treatment.

THE KNOWN“I knowwhat I have”THE UNKNOWNno guarantee, no probabilitystayinga choice that doesn't look like onethe blind leapbreaking everything, no way to correcta bounded stepwhat it teaches,the image that comesthe next step
From the known to the unknown, three paths. The loop returns to the starting point. The arc crosses everything in one go. The third moves forward from foothold to foothold, and each foothold teaches something before the next.

The courage of chaos therefore begins by acknowledging that we do not know. When we claim to know, we stop listening. To give up knowing is to give up what we claimed to know about reality, the knowledge that kept it frozen. There is no being if we claim that being is already fully there.

Holding without concluding, listening, moving forward one step

Holding. The poet John Keats gave the name “negative capability” to the capacity to remain in uncertainties and doubts without any irritable reaching after explanation. Jung describes something close with the transcendent function. When two opposing demands are held together long enough, a third term can appear, often in the form of an image.

Listening to the image. A woman dreams that a presence enters her bedroom at night and settles on her bed. She is frightened. Then she sees that it is a magnificent owl, looking at her, and she strokes it.

I have visited Jung’s house, on the shore of Lake Zurich. In the stairwell of the tower, the guide showed us a drawing he had made from a daydream of his youth. A great tower. On the upper floor, a library containing all the knowledge in the world. Below, an alchemical laboratory where lead is turned into gold. Jung followed this image all his life. This is what I call a symbolic life: giving enough value to the imaginal to let oneself be guided by it, and to act.

Taking a step. Between staying and breaking everything, there is a third move: a bounded step, that is, small, dated, reversible, whose aim is to learn something. A month of evening classes before changing career. Three weeks in the city before moving there. Levitt’s study does not say how to change. This step is a choice of prudence, and it is mine. It gives no guarantee. It gives information, and that is all uncertainty lets you take.

One does not take a life-changing decision in the depths of a depression, nor in the weeks following a bereavement. And when we stop being divided against ourselves, a void first forms around us. Many people were there for the person we were not. Other bonds often form, though nothing guarantees it. This void does not prove that we were wrong. Nor does it prove that we are right. If those who love you are all worried in the same direction, that deserves to be heard.

The system in one table
Faced with the unknownWhat one doesWhat one gainsWhat one loses
FlightOne stays, in the name of prudenceFamiliar contoursWhat might have been born
The blind leapOne breaks everything at onceReliefThe possibility of correcting course
CourageA bounded step, and one listensInformation, sometimes an imageCertainty

Courage of chaos = uncertainty borne + a reversible step + attention to what comes. The guarantee does not appear in the sum.

Two exercises, the bounded step and the solar map

Write down the decision you keep putting off, and the smallest reversible step that would teach you something about it. Give it a date.

Then imagine that you are a star in a solar system. The mass of each body organises the movement of the others. Place five or six bodies, their size showing their weight. Who, or what, carries the most weight in your life and decides your trajectory? To be at the centre of your own life, your judgement, your preferences and your imagination must carry the most weight.

Further reading
  • Søren Kierkegaard, The Concept of Anxiety, 1844.
  • John Keats, letter to George and Tom Keats, December 1817.
  • C. G. Jung, “The Transcendent Function”, written in 1916, published in 1957.
  • Frank H. Knight, Risk, Uncertainty and Profit, 1921.
  • Daniel Ellsberg, “Risk, ambiguity, and the Savage axioms”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1961.
  • William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser, “Status quo bias in decision making”, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1988.
  • Michel J. Dugas et al., “Generalized anxiety disorder: a preliminary test of a conceptual model”, Behaviour Research and Therapy, 1998.
  • Steven D. Levitt, “Heads or tails: the impact of a coin toss on major life decisions and subsequent happiness”, Review of Economic Studies, 2021.

If this text speaks to you, a first twenty-minute conversation is a chance to talk about it. Book a first conversation

20 min · free of charge Choose a time