Vincent Snickers

Home / Writings / Text VII

VII

Cutting the Gordian knot

Distancing yourself from a toxic parent or relative

By Vincent Snickers · 6 min read

For years you have been trying to settle a conflict with someone close to you, by speaking better, by explaining once more. If nothing has shifted, it is not for lack of effort. Some conflicts are not problems, and what is not a problem cannot be solved.

Paul Klee, Destroyed Labyrinth, 1939.
Paul Klee, Destroyed Labyrinth, 1939.

The same conversation for ten years

The phone rings and you already know what will be said. You hang up, and you replay the conversation for two days, with better arguments.

In 2019 the sociologist Karl Pillemer carried out the first large national American survey of family estrangement. Of 1,340 adults, 27% said they were cut off from a member of their family, and 10% from a parent or a child. Before the break there had often been years of that same conversation.

We readily believe that every difficulty in a relationship has a solution. It would be enough to communicate better, to be more patient, to forgive. If the conflict goes on, it is because we have not yet tried hard enough.

Most disagreements are never settled

The psychologist John Gottman followed couples for years. He estimates that 69% of their disagreements are perpetual. Couples who last do not resolve them. They keep talking about them without getting bogged down, often with humour. Gottman contrasts this dialogue with gridlock, where each waits for the other to give in. I believe this holds at least as true for families.

Your own experience confirms it: ten years of explanations have changed nothing, and the hypothesis of insufficient effort no longer holds.

A problem, or a knot

When we take as unresolved a problem that is in fact insoluble, we keep reopening it. We go on beating against a wall. That is so much attention and energy we deprive ourselves of, because it flows in the wrong direction.

The criterion is simple. A problem has a solution that depends, at least in part, on me. If the solution requires the other person to become someone else, it is a knot. It cannot be untied. It can be accommodated, or it can be cut.

Between the two lies the lasting disagreement we live with. We will never think alike about money, religion or bringing up children, and the relationship remains good. There is a knot when the disagreement strikes at who one is, and every contact replays it.

Does the solutiondepend on me?yesnoA PROBLEMit requires effortA SITUATIONclose a subjectchange the settingspace outsuspendbreak offchoose the smallest that protectsthe knot: back to the questionhope kept alive, assumed debt,years already given
A single question sorts things out. If the solution depends on me, it is a problem. If not, it is a situation, and one chooses a rung. The knot is the loop that keeps bringing us back to the question instead of answering it.

Why do we persist? Mechanisms known from elsewhere help us understand.

The unfinished task. In 1927 Bluma Zeigarnik argued that we remember better what has been interrupted. This finding replicates poorly. What does hold is the tendency, described by her colleague Maria Ovsiankina, to resume an interrupted task of one’s own accord.

What we have already given. This is the sunk-cost trap, described by Hal Arkes and Catherine Blumer. The years given become the reason to give more.

Hope kept alive. Ferster and Skinner’s work with animals showed that a behaviour rewarded from time to time, without regularity, is the hardest to extinguish. The parent who is tender one time in ten keeps expectation alive more surely than the one who always is.

The debt. The family therapist Ivan Boszormenyi-Nagy described the silent bookkeeping of families. The child feels indebted, and this debt operates without ever being spoken. He called this invisible loyalties.

Bread. What holds us back is also material security. Cutting ties can mean moving house, living somewhere smaller. Those who choose bread give up saying what they think. They prefer the prison of the familiar to the discomfort of leaving it.

We stop solving, we choose a distance

A young woman was being suffocated by a mother who commented on all her choices. Letting an image of the situation come to her, she saw herself being strangled by hands that had turned into branches. Returning to it, she saw herself running towards a hut and locking all its bolts. She understood that what mattered was not helping her mother or making up for her shortcomings. What mattered was no longer letting herself be suffocated. The guilt fell away.

Giving up the hope that the other will change is not decided in a day. It is a mourning, for the parent one would have wanted, and it comes in waves.

There is always a sword of Damocles above a relationship, and it is respect that holds it up. Respect, etymologically, means looking again. If I deny your needs, your sensitivity, your values, I attack your integrity, and the sword must fall.

Cutting does not mean breaking off. The right distance is measured by what it protects, and it is chosen on a ladder.

Choose the smallest rung that truly protects you. This ladder applies between adults.

Coercive control is another matter. It can be recognised by three things: you are afraid of the other’s reactions, you justify yourself for everything, and you have gradually cut yourself off from those who could offer another view. In that case, do not announce that you are taking your distance without first talking to a professional or a specialised organisation. In France, 3919 is the helpline for domestic violence.

The system in a table
A problemA knot
The solution dependsOn me, at least in partOn the other changing
AttemptsMove things forwardBring you back to the same point
What I expectA resultThat the other become someone else
What it asks of meAn effortA mourning, then a decision

Knot = what only the other could change + the hope that they will + a debt never reckoned up. Take away the hope, and what remains is a distance to choose.

Exercise

Write down the relationship problem that occupies you most. How long have you been trying to solve it? What would the other person have to change for it to be solved?

If the answer does not depend on you, go back to the ladder. Which rung would protect you, and what is holding you back from taking it: hope, debt or bread?

Further reading
  • Bluma Zeigarnik, “Das Behalten erledigter und unerledigter Handlungen”, Psychologische Forschung, 1927.
  • Charles B. Ferster and B. F. Skinner, Schedules of Reinforcement, 1957.
  • Ivan Boszormenyi-Nagy and Geraldine Spark, Invisible Loyalties, 1973.
  • Hal R. Arkes and Catherine Blumer, “The psychology of sunk cost”, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1985.
  • John M. Gottman and Nan Silver, The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work, 1999.
  • Karl Pillemer, Fault Lines: Fractured Families and How to Mend Them, 2020.

If this text speaks to you, a first twenty-minute conversation is a chance to talk about it. Book a first conversation

20 min · free of charge Choose a time