VI
The death of the father
Freeing yourself from your parents’ gaze and judgement
By Vincent Snickers · 7 min read
We are told we must kill the father, and we take it to mean opposing him or moving away from him. Those who have done so still hear his voice. What has to end is a specific power: the power to decide for you what is real, possible and permitted.

A voice that does not present itself as an opinion
You are forty. You are hesitating over leaving a job, moving in with someone, writing. Before you have even weighed the pros and cons, a sentence is already there. “That’s not a real job.” “People like us don’t do that.” “You’ll regret it.”
This sentence presents itself as a fact, never as a view, and in adults who are otherwise free and capable it decides their work, their relationship, the place where they live.
We believe we have only three answers to it. Obey, telling ourselves it is wisdom. Rebel, do the opposite, cut all ties. Or look for a better guide, a master, a doctrine, an institution, sometimes a therapist.
All three exits lead back to the same place
Submission is paid for with one’s own life. It is Nietzsche’s camel.
Rebellion keeps the father in command. I do the opposite of what he would have wanted, and it is still he who sets the direction, since I simply take it in reverse. The psychiatrist Murray Bowen described the radical version under the name of emotional cutoff. We break off, we move away, we stop speaking, and the voice travels with us. Putting distance between oneself and a destructive parent can be necessary, but it is not enough to silence the voice.
Substitution replaces the father, and we remain someone’s child. I have done it. I once dreamt that I asked a man I admired to accept me at his side. He refused, because of my father. I came back down, picked up a sword from the ground and learned on my own how to wield it. The dream was telling me to stop looking for a father.
If none of the three sets us free, it is because we have mistaken the adversary.
Three fathers, one of them a power we do not see
The real father. A man, with his own history and his own fears.
The internalised father. Jung calls it the imago. It is the image of the father as the child built it, made of the real man, of what the child projected onto him, and enlarged by dependence. It outlives the father’s death. It is the imago that speaks in the sentence.
The power to define. To say what is. A mother can hold it, and so can a Church (one calls the priest “Father”), a school, a milieu, a boss. Lacan also distinguishes three fathers, the real, the imaginary and the symbolic, but his division is not mine. For him the symbolic father is a law to which the father himself is subject. I am speaking here of a power that a person or a milieu exercises over another.
We oppose the first. It is the other two that govern.
Freud gave the name superego to the inner heir of the parents’ authority. The superego commands and forbids. When we disobey it, we feel guilty. This guilt can remain unconscious, Freud notes, but it keeps the form of a prohibition: something within us says no.
The power I am describing acts one step earlier. It does not say “you must not become a musician”. It says “being a musician is not a real job”. It draws the map instead of putting up a barrier. And you cannot disobey a map. You simply do not see what is not on it. What is invisible is invincible.
A prohibition is recognised by guilt, a definition by obviousness. Whatever seems to you “obvious”, “impossible” or “not for me” without your ever having checked it is very likely an inherited verdict. Cognitive therapies speak of core beliefs. I keep the image of the father because it says where the sentence draws its authority from. Obviousness guards the border as long as we do not cross it. Guilt comes afterwards, once we are on the other side.
How does this take hold? In 2004 Avi Assor, Guy Roth and Edward Deci questioned students about their childhood. Those who remembered affection granted on condition that they conform described a pressure felt as internal, and a self-esteem that rises and falls with their results. The child no longer needs to be watched: he watches himself.
Taking back authority, and bearing what it costs
The psychoanalyst Hans Loewald put it in 1979. To become an adult, psychically, is to take over the authority that belonged to the parents, to decide for oneself what has value and what one will do. In psychic reality, he says, this amounts to parricide. The act has a price: guilt.
As early as 1965 Arnold Modell had described patients who did not feel they had the right to a life of their own. Since then we have spoken of separation guilt. Guilt over a wrong signals that I have harmed someone, and it calls for reparation. Separation guilt signals that I have done things differently, and it asks only to be borne. A parent can be hurt without your having done them any wrong. Confusing the two is the most common mistake. We then repair what is not broken, by going back under the father’s law.
A murder leaves a corpse. Here no one dies; it is a reign that comes to an end. You recognise it by this: at last you can look at the real father as a man, neither giant nor monster, someone who also had a father.
This way of looking has a cost, which we mistake for guilt: it is a mourning. We give up the father we would have liked to have, the one who would have come round in the end, understood and approved. As long as we are still waiting for his blessing, his reign goes on. And seeing a father as a man obliges you neither to excuse him nor to see him again. Where there has been violence or incest, distance remains legitimate, and this work is done with support.
Three markers help you observe yourself.
- The grammar of the voice. Inherited judgement speaks in the second person, in the tone of general truth, “you can’t”, “that isn’t done”. Your own speaks in the first person and accepts that it may be wrong, “I prefer”, “I’m going to try”.
- The source of the proof. Ask yourself how you know. If the answer is “it’s always been that way”, you are holding a verdict.
- The day after a choice. After a decision taken against the father’s law, guilt rises in the days that follow. If no one has been harmed, it is separation guilt. It most often fades once you stop obeying it.
| Position | Who says what is | What one feels | What it costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Submission | The father | Security, then weariness | One’s own life |
| Rebellion | The father, in reverse | Anger | The same dependence |
| Substitution | Another father | Relief, then disappointment | Remaining someone’s child |
| Death of the father | Me, subject to error | Separation guilt, sadness, then calm | Certainty |
Death of the father = authority taken back + separation guilt borne − the search for a replacement.
Write ten sentences beginning with “you can’t”, “that’s not” or “people like us”. For each one, answer three questions. Who said it first? Have I ever checked it? What would I do this year if it were false?
Then list what makes you feel at fault. Beside each line, write “wrong” if someone has been harmed, “separation” if you have only done things differently.
- Sigmund Freud, The Ego and the Id, 1923.
- C. G. Jung, Symbols of Transformation, on the imago.
- Jacques Lacan, The Seminar, Book IV, The Object Relation, 1956-1957, Seuil, 1994.
- Arnold H. Modell, “On having the right to a life: an aspect of the superego’s development”, International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 1965.
- Murray Bowen, Family Therapy in Clinical Practice, 1978.
- Hans W. Loewald, “The waning of the Oedipus complex”, Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 1979.
- Avi Assor, Guy Roth and Edward L. Deci, “The emotional costs of parents’ conditional regard”, Journal of Personality, 2004.
If this text speaks to you, a first twenty-minute conversation is a chance to talk about it. Book a first conversation