Vincent Snickers

Home / Writings / Text III

III

The shadow

The shadow according to Jung: what we refuse to see in ourselves

By Vincent Snickers · 5 min read

We think the shadow is our bad side and that it has to be kept on a leash. It is this very idea that makes it dangerous. The shadow is everything you had to cut away from yourself in order to be accepted, and the best of you is part of it.

Léon Spilliaert, Vertigo, 1908.
Léon Spilliaert, Vertigo, 1908.

The same conflicts, with different people

A colleague puts himself forward in a meeting. Nothing serious. You are still thinking about it that evening. The intensity of your reaction far exceeds what he did.

We all know this. Looking at our own lives, each of us can also see that the same type of person exasperates us from one job to the next, from one relationship to the next.

Two explanations are current. According to the first, the problem is the other person, and it is enough to keep away from them. According to the second, more cultivated, we all have a dark side, made of anger, envy and selfishness, and maturity consists in controlling it.

What we drive out comes back

Driving a thought away brings it back. In 1987 Daniel Wegner asked volunteers not to think of a white bear. When they were then allowed to, the thought came back more often than in those who had been free to think about it from the start. The effect is modest, and it concerns thoughts. Yet it points to something useful: holding back from acting works; forbidding oneself to know works badly.

What we drive out of ourselves, we see in others. Ten years later, Leonard Newman, Kimberley Duff and Roy Baumeister observed that people who strive to push away the idea of a flaw they fear they have perceive it more in others.

We also reject qualities. This is a clinical observation. Excessive admiration and envy follow the same mechanism as irritation. If the shadow were only the evil in us, we could not understand why we attribute to others an authority or a freedom that we do not dare to live.

The shadow is what was refused, without sorting

Jung calls the shadow the part of the personality that the ego refuses to recognise as its own, because it contradicts the image the ego has of itself. It is not the whole of the unconscious. The poet Robert Bly gave the simplest image of it: a long bag we drag behind us. As children, we throw into it whatever displeases our parents, then our teachers, then the group. In it there is anger and greed. There is also ambition, authority, loud joy.

THE EGOwhat hasbeen acceptedTHE OTHERprojectionscreenTHE SHADOWthe bagrepressed“what displeases”projectedirritation: a forbidden traitenvy: a quality I dare not liveintegratedrecognise, find the context, give it measure
What displeases goes down into the bag. What is in the bag does not disappear: it is seen in the other, in black or in gold. Integration is the only path that brings it back to the ego.

Repression fits in one sentence: I am afraid to be, so I give up being. Then I no longer know that I gave it up. What is not expected displeases, quite literally. Yet our criteria for what pleases come to us from the collective. We cannot be ourselves without accepting that we will displease.

Two operations look alike, and are often confused. To suppress is to set something aside knowingly. I feel my anger and keep it quiet. To repress is to no longer know: the anger no longer even appears to be mine. The shadow feeds on the second. The first is part of living together.

Repression is a disfigurement. The being that cuts parts of itself away is diminished, and it compensates. The powerlessness it has imposed on itself, it often imposes on someone else.

Two shadows must still be distinguished. The shadow of the repressed presupposes that something was present and then torn away by active opposition: a father, a religion, codes. The shadow of forgetting is made of what never came to be, because something else took up all the room. The first defends itself; the second does not know itself.

The shadow also has two colours. Irritation signals a trait I forbid myself. Envy often signals a quality I do not dare to live, what the analyst Robert Johnson called the gold in the shadow.

It remains to avoid taking everything for a projection. The other person may really have that flaw. There is projection when the reaction is out of proportion, when it recurs with different people, and when it comes with a kind of fascination. When someone lies, humiliates or hits, anger is responding to a fact.

Neither tame it nor unleash it: integrate it

Faced with the shadow, we can do four things. Push it out of awareness, and it comes back. Project it, and we make enemies. Obey it without seeing it, and we do damage. Or integrate it, that is, recognise the trait as our own, find the context in which it is a resource, and give it measure. Anger condemned in the absolute becomes once more, in its proper place, the capacity to say no.

A man who is always gentle and agreeable gets left. He dreams of his double, who walks forward into the light with an empty eye socket, and it is towards this damaged face that the woman runs. What he hid in order to please was what the relationship lacked.

Faced with an irritation or an excessive admiration, ask yourself four questions.

The system in one table
What I do with the shadowWhat happensWhat it costs
Drive it out of my awarenessIt comes back, often elsewhereEnergy, symptoms
Project itI fight it in othersRepeated conflicts
Obey it without seeing itIt acts in my placeActions I do not understand
Integrate itIt becomes a resourceThe flattering image I had of myself

Shadow = what I am − what I recognise of myself. Integration = recognition + context + measure.

Exercise

Think of three people you find unbearable, and two you admire too much. Remove from the list those who have genuinely harmed you. Put each of the others through the four questions. You will have the map of your shadow, the black one and the golden one.

Further reading
  • C. G. Jung, Aion, chapter “The Shadow”.
  • Robert Bly, A Little Book on the Human Shadow, 1988.
  • Robert A. Johnson, Owning Your Own Shadow, 1991.
  • Daniel M. Wegner, David J. Schneider, Samuel R. Carter and Teri L. White, “Paradoxical effects of thought suppression”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1987.
  • Leonard S. Newman, Kimberley J. Duff and Roy F. Baumeister, “A new look at defensive projection”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1997.

If this text speaks to you, a first twenty-minute conversation is a chance to talk about it. Book a first conversation

20 min · free of charge Choose a time